Becoming a referee

Each breast cancer protocol and review undergoes peer review before it is published on The Cochrane Library (CLib). The role of the referee is to provide feedback to authors on the content and design of protocols and reviews. Referees represent a range of disciplines such as clinicians, methodologists and consumers. It is up to each individual as to how much they referee, and there is no obligation to accept work when approached. Referee comments are anonymous and referees may choose to review changes made as a result of their comments or leave this in the hands of the editorial base. Referees provide their expertise and time on a voluntary basis.

The CBCG has designed a generic checklist to guide referees when providing feedback. Each referee is therefore encouraged to comment only on those sections of the protocol or review relevant to their expertise. Full guidelines for referees including the policies of the CBCG in relation to refereeing are available.

Disclaimer